
Uncover the Chilling History of Illinois’ Cave-In-Rock and America’s First Serial Killers
What if I told you one of Illinois’ most stunning natural landmarks once hid America’s first serial killers? The story of the Harpe Brothers is as chilling as the dark recesses of Cave-In-Rock itself, where beauty and horror collide.
Violent, Motive-Less Crimes: The Harpe Brothers' Illinois Connection
The Harpe Brothers’ killing spree left a trail of terror across the early American frontier, their crimes shockingly violent and seemingly without motive. These infamous outlaws found temporary refuge in Cave-In-Rock, Illinois—a natural wonder turned nightmarish hideout.
What Is Cave-In-Rock?

Nestled along the Ohio River in southern Illinois, Cave-In-Rock State Park in Hardin County offers visitors breathtaking views of high bluffs and a heavily wooded landscape. Its crown jewel is the massive, 55-foot-wide cave carved into limestone over thousands of years.
While this natural marvel now invites hikers and history buffs alike, it was once a haven for unspeakable crimes. In the late 1700s, Cave-In-Rock served as a hideout for river pirates and outlaws—including the infamous Harpe Brothers.
Who Were the Harpe Brothers?
Micajah and Wiley Harpe, better known as the Harpe Brothers, were America’s first documented serial killers. Born in the 18th century, these men turned the Tennessee and Kentucky frontier into their killing ground. Their spree was marked by brutal, unprovoked murders that spared no one—not settlers, not travelers, and not even their accomplices.
The Harpe Brothers’ Hideout
On the run from authorities in Kentucky, the Harpe Brothers crossed the Ohio River into Illinois. Their reputation for barbarity preceded them, but the natural seclusion of Cave-In-Rock made it an ideal hideout. However, their violent history caught up with them even there. The cave wasn’t just a place to evade capture—it was also the site of some of their murders.
Explore the Harpe Brothers’ Dark Legacy
Today, visitors to Cave-In-Rock State Park can marvel at its natural beauty while reflecting on its chilling history. Standing inside this limestone cave, one can only imagine the terror of those who encountered the Harpe Brothers.
Micajah and Wiley were known for their brutality, often committing murders without apparent motive. Their victims included men, women, and children, and their methods ranged from shootings to brutal mutilations. The Harpe Brothers' notoriety peaked during the late 1700s, as authorities struggled to catch them.
While looking for books written about the Harpe Brothers on Amazon, I clicked on the first one that popped up, Killer Brothers: A Biography of the Harpe Brothers – America’s First Serial Killers. The first reviewer, rosekrystofolski, shared some horrific details about these killers:
Great mini book about Micajah and Wiley Harpe, the first American Serial Killers and Team Killers. Back in the 1700s the Harpes were frontiersmen who were evil sociopathic murderers who committed between 20 and 100 murders. Until they were tracked down in the woods after slaughtering a woman and her Baby son and then burned their cabin down. The victim's husband and father caught up to Micajah (also known as Big Harpe- a lovely man who once killed his infant daughter by grabbing her by the feet and bashing her head against a tree because her crying woke him up) after shooting him a couple times and then cut his head off. Wiley Harpe was apprehended and then executed after bringing the head of an outlaw to the police to try and claim a reward he had on his head. He almost got away with it, but was then recognized as "Little Harpe" and decapitated, his head put on a pike as a warning to other criminals
The Harpe Brothers' reign of terror left an indelible mark on American history. Before their heads wound up on those pikes, they found brief refuge, here in Illinois.
Cave-in-Rock Illinois the Hideout For America's First Serial Killers
Gallery Credit: Steve Shannon
25 True Crime Locations: What Do They Look Like Today?
More From 97 ZOK








