5 Highest-Rated Italian Restaurants in Rockford According to Yelp

Italian food lovers in Rockford are spoiled for choice with some truly outstanding dining options. Thanks to Yelp reviews, we’ve rounded up the top five Italian restaurants in town that are sure to satisfy your cravings for pizza, pasta, and everything in between.

I have lived in Rockford for three decades and the area is blessed with some of the most amazing Italian restaurants. My wife and I crave these flavors so often and have been to so many places, I was shocked that the number one place on this list is somewhere we haven't been. That changes now!

The 5 Highest-Rated Italian Restaurants in Rockford According to Yelp

If you’re craving Italian cuisine in Rockford, Yelp reviewers have spoken. As of January 2024, these are the top five Italian restaurants in town based on diner reviews compiled by Stacker. Whether you're in the mood for pizza, pasta, or a cozy dining atmosphere, this list has you covered.

5. Dough Bros. Pizza

Get our free mobile app

Address: 116 N Madison St, Rockford, IL
Dough Bros. Pizza offers a casual dining experience with a focus on creative, delicious pizzas. Known for its fresh ingredients and unique toppings, Dough Bros. is a favorite spot for both locals and visitors looking for a laid-back pizza night. Yelp reviews.

4. Primo's Pizza

Address: 1712 E Riverside Blvd, Loves Park, IL
Primo's Pizza has built a loyal following with its thin-crust pizzas and generous portions. This family-owned establishment is a go-to spot for traditional Italian comfort food in a relaxed setting. Yelp reviews.

3. Lino's

Address: 5611 E State St, Rockford, IL
A Rockford institution since 1972, Lino's is beloved for its old-world charm and authentic Italian recipes. From hand-tossed pizzas to homemade pasta dishes, this restaurant combines great food with a nostalgic atmosphere. Yelp reviews.

2. John's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Address: 2914 11th St, Rockford, IL
John's is the definition of a neighborhood gem, serving up hearty Italian dishes and pizza since 1966. With its welcoming vibe and flavorful menu, it’s a classic stop for anyone seeking a satisfying Italian meal. Yelp reviews.

MORE: Chefs Agree, Illinois Pizza Joint Serves Best Slice in America

1. Jo-Jo's Pizza & Pub

Address: 2511 N Alpine Rd, Rockford, IL
Taking the top spot, Jo-Jo's Pizza & Pub is praised for its consistently delicious pizza and friendly service. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Jo-Jo’s menu offers something for everyone, from traditional pies to Italian favorites. Yelp reviews.

Good lord, which one will you try first?

MORE: Illinois Pizzerias With The Highest Scores From Dave Portnoy's One Bite Reviews